Kitty is finally introduced to McAllister's gay brother, Jason, and despite promising not to, she is unable to resist the urge to set him up with Kevin. She intentionally fails to mention to Kevin that he is McAllister's brother. Throughout the date Kevin repeatedly insults McAllister before Jason makes his excuses and leaves.

Justin tells his family that he is disappointed with their neglectful attitude towards their half sister and they all respond by calling her up immediately to arrange time together. Kitty, however, refuses as she is still uncomfortable with the idea of meeting her illegitimate sister.

Meanwhile, Nora bumps into old family friends and former rivals who used to compete with her family for an evening they called 'Game Night'. They suggest to host another of these nights as the Walkers are desperate to win the competition and Sarah invites Rebecca in an effort to include her in their family activities. Kitty is visibly shocked when she sees how much Rebecca resembles their late father.

Rebecca meets Joe and after explaining that she used to play the guitar, Joe offers her an old one of his to practice with. They get along well and she even confesses that her ex-boyfriend was the same age as him. When she struggles to play the guitar, he offers to help but before long, they pause to exchange a lingering glance.

After receiving a tearful phonecall from Rebecca, Justin rushes to see her and find out what is wrong. She claims that Joe kissed her.